The Art of Letting Go:
What Montaigne Knew About Freedom We’ve Forgotten
Five centuries ago, a Frenchman quit public life, climbed into a tower full of books, and began writing about his own contradictions. What he discovered — that we are imprisoned chiefly by our own minds — is the most useful thing you will read this week.
Imagine this. You spend your entire life trying to fit in. Striving for approval. Shaping yourself according to expectations that are not even your own. You seek validation, fear judgment, and quietly believe your worth is measured by how others see you. But what if everything you have been taught about caring is the very thing holding you back? What if the key to confidence, to peace, to a life that actually feels like yours, is not in controlling more — but in finally letting go?
Michel de Montaigne, a French nobleman writing in the late sixteenth century, spent the second half of his life thinking carefully about this question. At thirty-eight he retired from public office, withdrew to a tower on his family estate, and began writing what he called Essais — “attempts.” He was not building a system. He was watching himself. He noticed that most human suffering had nothing to do with real catastrophe. It came from the relentless inner machinery of approval-seeking, image-management, and the doomed effort to control outcomes that were never ours to control.
His conclusion is the most quietly radical idea in Western thought: the moment you stop caring about the wrong things, your life starts arranging itself around the right ones.
i.The cage of approval
Begin honestly. How much of your daily stress comes from trying to satisfy expectations that do not even belong to you? How often do you hold yourself back because you are afraid of being judged? How much of your mental energy is spent rehearsing conversations, replaying small humiliations, or worrying about things that, in the long run, will mean almost nothing?
Montaigne saw this clearly. He noticed that we are, most of us, prisoners of our own minds — caught in loops of comparison, self-doubt, and imagined audiences. He asked the question almost nobody asks: why do we let the opinions of strangers determine our choices? Why do we cling to control when life is, by its nature, uncertain? Why do we chase definitions of success we did not write?
The cage feels real because we built it ourselves, slowly, one decision at a time. But cages we build, we can also unlock.
ii.What “not caring” actually means
This is where most people misunderstand the idea, so it is worth getting it right. Letting go does not mean indifference. It is not laziness. It is not withdrawing from the world or pretending you have no responsibilities. Montaigne did not become a hermit; he served as mayor of Bordeaux during plague years and negotiated between warring factions in the French Wars of Religion. He was deeply engaged with life. What he refused to be was owned by it.
Letting go means freeing yourself from three specific weights: the constant need for approval, the fear of rejection, and the exhausting habit of overanalyzing every action. It means engaging with the world fully, but without bleeding for outcomes you cannot guarantee. It means caring deeply about what is yours to care about — your values, the people in front of you, the work in your hands — and letting the rest pass through you.
iii.The paradox of release
Think about the most magnetic people you have ever met. The ones whose presence calmed a room. Were they the ones constantly explaining themselves, fishing for reassurance, sanding their personalities down to be liked? Or were they the ones who seemed at ease — unbothered, amused, unapologetically themselves?
This is the paradox Montaigne saw centuries before modern psychology caught up. Authenticity is magnetic. The moment you stop performing, people lean in. The moment you stop chasing, things start arriving. Detach from the fear of judgment and you gain something more valuable than approval ever could be: freedom. Freedom to take a risk without rehearsing it ten times. Freedom to speak without auditioning your sentence. Freedom to simply exist without weighing yourself on someone else’s scale.
And the strange consequence is that life — actual material life — begins to improve. Relationships become more honest because you are no longer managing them. Opportunities find you because you are no longer flinching from them. Decisions become easier because you are answering the right question: not what should I want? but what do I actually want?
iv.Embracing imperfection
Montaigne wrote, in one form or another, the same sentence many times across his essays: I am myself the matter of my book. What he meant was that he was not going to pretend to be wiser, calmer, or more consistent than he actually was. He admitted to laziness, to fear of pain, to a poor memory, to changing his mind. He wrote about his digestion. He found the whole project of human dignity slightly absurd, including his own.
This was not modesty. It was strategy. By accepting his own imperfection on the page, he disarmed it. He understood that striving for absolute control over how you appear is an exhausting, unwinnable war. Life is unpredictable; you will fail; you will be misunderstood; you will be ridiculous sometimes. Every great thinker, leader, and artist in history has been. They simply refused to let that fact stop them.
Imagine how light you would feel if you stopped over-analyzing every decision. If you treated failure not as evidence of your unworthiness but as a fee paid for being alive and trying. This is not a trick of perspective. It is a more accurate view of how the world actually works.
v.Why detachment deepens connection
Here is the counter-intuitive part. Letting go does not isolate you from people. It draws them closer. Most of the friction in our relationships is the friction of expectation — the quiet, often unspoken demand that the other person be slightly different than they are. Less anxious. More attentive. More like us.
Montaigne, who lost his closest friend Étienne de La Boétie in his early thirties and never quite recovered from it, knew something about love. He understood that real connection requires letting the other person be themselves — fully, inconveniently, without our edits. Those who can do this are the ones who tend to be deeply loved in return. They do not suffocate. They do not extract. They are simply present.
Notice this in your own life. The people who most demand your attention often receive the least of it. The ones at peace with themselves draw others in without trying. This is not a trick of charisma; it is the natural physics of human relationships. You cannot pull someone toward you by gripping. You can only become someone worth moving toward.
vi.Why we resist
If letting go is so liberating, why is it so rare? The honest answer is fear. Specifically, the fear that if we loosen our grip even a little, everything we have built will collapse. We have been trained to believe that control equals safety — that worrying hard enough, planning thoroughly enough, and managing impressions carefully enough will somehow keep the universe in line.
It will not. It never has. No amount of vigilance prevents the unexpected. No amount of replaying a conversation changes what was said. No amount of refreshing the inbox makes the email arrive faster. Worry feels productive. It is not. It is a tax we pay on imagined futures, and the receipt is always the same: nothing.
Montaigne’s invitation is not recklessness. It is the substitution of anxious control for thoughtful presence. Plan, yes. Care, yes. Then release the result. The future will be what it will be, and the version of you that arrives there will be the one you built today by what you chose to carry — and what you chose to set down.
vii.The final realization
The deepest moments of any life — the ones you will remember on your last day — were almost never the ones you scheduled. They were the unguarded conversations, the work that came easily because you stopped strangling it, the love you fell into when you finally stopped looking. Some things in life cannot be forced. They can only be allowed.
The artist who stops worrying whether the work will be praised, and so makes something true. The entrepreneur who stops fearing failure, takes the risk, and changes an industry. The person who stops searching desperately for love and, in that softer space, becomes lovable. This is not magic. It is what happens when you finally stop standing in your own way.
So ask the question Montaigne would ask. What are you carrying that no longer serves you? What expectation, fear, or attachment is taking energy you would rather spend elsewhere? And what would your life actually look like if, starting now, you simply set it down?
You do not need to control everything to be happy. You do not need to prove anything to anyone. You do not need to fear uncertainty, because life is uncertain by nature, and that is precisely what gives it shape. Wisdom, Montaigne knew, is not in trying to conquer life. It is in learning to dance with it — clumsily, honestly, as yourself.
The moment you stop caring about the wrong things, the right things find their way to you. That is not motivational hyperbole. It is, after five centuries, still true.
Questions Readers Ask
Honest answers to the things people wonder when they first encounter Montaigne.
Doesn’t “not caring” just mean becoming apathetic or lazy?
How do I stop caring what other people think of me?
Who was Michel de Montaigne and why does his philosophy still matter?
Isn’t trying to control my life just being responsible?
How is this different from Stoicism?
What’s one thing I can do today to start practicing this?
Further ReadingReferences & Sources
- Montaigne, Michel de. The Complete Essays. Translated by M. A. Screech, Penguin Classics, 1993. The definitive English edition of the Essais, originally published in three books between 1580 and 1595.
- Bakewell, Sarah. How to Live: A Life of Montaigne in One Question and Twenty Attempts at an Answer. Other Press, 2010. The most widely-read modern biography; warm, accessible, and faithful to Montaigne’s spirit.
- Frame, Donald M. Montaigne: A Biography. Harcourt, Brace & World, 1965. The standard scholarly biography in English, by Montaigne’s most important twentieth-century translator.
- Zweig, Stefan. Montaigne. Translated by Will Stone, Pushkin Press, 2015. A short, urgent biographical essay written under the shadow of war — Zweig saw Montaigne as a model for keeping one’s mind free in unfree times.
- Compagnon, Antoine. A Summer with Montaigne. Translated by Tina Kover, Europa Editions, 2019. Forty short broadcasts on Montaigne’s enduring relevance, originally aired on French radio.
- Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, “Michel de Montaigne.” A rigorous, free, and continuously updated overview of his thought. Available at plato.stanford.edu.
Leave a Reply